Systematic Investment Plans (SIP) and Systematic Withdrawal Plans (SWP) are two popular ways of managing investments in mutual funds. Each has its unique advantages and caters to different investor needs. Comparing the returns on SIPs and SWPs using online calculators can help investors decide which option aligns best with their financial goals.
Â
This article provides a simple, step-by-step guide on using SIP and SWP calculators to compare potential returns.
What is a SIP Calculator?
A SIP calculator is a simple tool for estimating the returns on mutual fund investments made through SIPs. These calculators consider your monthly investment amount, the investment duration, and the expected rate of return to give you an approximate maturity amount.
Â
Although SIP calculators provide a great estimate, it’s important to remember that actual returns can vary depending on market conditions. SIP calculators don’t consider exit loads or expense ratios, so investors must know that the real returns differ slightly.
What is a SWP Calculator?
A SWP calculator helps you determine how much you can regularly withdraw from a lump sum investment in a mutual fund. The calculator considers the initial amount invested, the monthly withdrawal, and the expected return on investment. It gives you a clear idea of how long your investment will last based on the amount and withdrawal frequency.
Â
Like the SIP calculator, the SWP calculator provides an estimate, as actual market performance can fluctuate over time.
Key Benefits of Using SIP and SWP Calculators
Both SIP and SWP calculators come with several benefits, making them essential tools for any mutual fund investor:
Â
Ease of Use: These calculators are easy to use. You just need to enter a few values, such as the amount you want to invest or withdraw, the duration, and the expected return rate, and the calculators do the math for you.
Time-Saving: Instead of manually calculating your investment’s returns or duration, these calculators provide instant results, saving you time and effort.
Informed Decision-Making: You can plan your investments more effectively using a SIP calculator or SWP calculator. These tools give you a clear picture of potential returns, helping you align your financial goals with the right investment strategy.
Clear Visualisation of Growth: SIP calculators show how your regular investments will grow. SWP calculators demonstrate how much you can withdraw from your investments without depleting the corpus too soon.
How Do SIP Calculators Work?
SIP calculators work on a simple compound interest formula to calculate the estimated returns on your investments. The formula is:
Â
M = P × ({[1 + i]^n – 1} / i) × (1 + i)
Â
Where:
M is the maturity amount
P is the amount invested at regular intervals
i is the periodic interest rate
n is the number of payments made
Â
For instance, if you invest ₹1,000 per month for 12 months at an annual interest rate of 12%, your returns will be calculated based on the monthly interest rate (12%/12 = 1%). Using this formula, the SIP calculator estimates how much your investment will grow over time.
Â
How Do SWP Calculators Work?
An SWP calculator operates on the principle of reverse compounding. Instead of adding to your investment, you are withdrawing a fixed sum regularly. The formula considers the initial amount, periodic withdrawal, and the rate of interest to estimate the longevity of your investment.
Â
For example, if you invested ₹1,00,000 in a mutual fund and decided to withdraw ₹10,000 per month, the SWP calculator will show you how long your money will last based on an expected interest rate. While the withdrawals reduce the total corpus, the remaining amount earns returns.
Comparing SIP and SWP Returns Using Calculators
Here are the steps for comparing returns using the SIP and SWP calculators.
Â
Enter Your Investment Amount:
For the SIP calculator, enter the amount you wish to invest monthly (e.g., ₹5,000 per month).
For the SWP calculator, enter the initial lump sum investment (e.g., ₹1,00,000).
Select the Tenure:
In the SIP calculator, choose the years you plan to stay invested.
In the SWP calculator, choose the withdrawal period or how long you want to withdraw from your investment.
Set the Expected Rate of Return:
Input the expected rate of return for both SIP and SWP calculators. Typically, you can expect 8%-12% for equity mutual funds, which vary based on market conditions.
View the Results:
The SIP calculator will show you the estimated total value of your investment at the end of the chosen tenure.
The SWP calculator will show you how long your lump sum will last and how much you can withdraw each month without running out of money too quickly.
When to Use SIP vs SWP?
SIP (Systematic Investment Plan): Ideal for individuals who want to build wealth over time by investing small, regular amounts. SIP is often used by younger investors or those with a long-term financial goal, such as retirement savings or a child’s education.
SWP (Systematic Withdrawal Plan): Best suited for those who need regular income from their investments, such as retirees. SWP ensures that you have a steady flow of money each month while still allowing your remaining investment to grow.
Advantages of SIP and SWP
SIP Advantages:
Promotes financial discipline by making regular investments.
Mitigates the risks of market volatility by averaging out purchase costs over time.
Compounds return on the invested amount, generating long-term growth.
Â
SWP Advantages:
It provides a consistent income stream, making it ideal for retirees.
Allows the remaining investment to earn returns, even as you withdraw funds.
Flexibility in choosing the withdrawal amount and frequency.
Conclusion
SIP and SWP offer valuable tools for investors. A SIP calculator helps plan investments and estimate returns, perfect for gradual wealth growth. An SWP calculator is essential for regular withdrawals while maintaining an invested corpus. Comparing both plans using online calculators helps make informed decisions tailored to financial goals.
Â
Â
Â
Â
Â
